Verdict Day received "mixed or average reviews" on both platforms according to the review aggregation website Metacritic.[19][20] Critics pointed the difficulty for newcomers to understand the game and weak story. Most critics agreed that the game would be successful with those who are already into the series but would suffer to add new players to its fanbase. On a more positive light, IGN, although acknowledging the weak graphics and confusing menus of the PS3 version, remarked: "a special kind of magic here that most games would never even attempt."[13]
In Japan, Famitsu gave it a score of two nines and two eights for a total of 34 out of 40. One editor wrote: "The game's pretty difficult and you have to use a ton of buttons, which makes the hurdles seem pretty high at first. But the more you plug away at it, the more you can really feel how much better you're getting at it, which is nice." Another wrote: "The game's focused primarily on online play and that may scare off some pla
